Located in a very cute small old town area on the water. Toby's definitely gives off dive bar vibes. Very pleasantly surprised by the food...everything was great. Must have the local Penn Cove mussels! Very good price! We also ordered from the specials menu...mussels chowder and trio fish n chips. The fish didn't look that great but tasted so much better than it looked...very good! Not your average fish n chips fish. Service is fun as there is a bit of a banter but all in good fun! Recommend but must be over 21 since it is a bar.

After lots of recommendations to stop, we've now been twice and love it. The Thai mussels are to die for and burgers hit the spot. The clam and seafood chowders are delish and hearty. Service must differ based on when you go. We've always had amazing service from Kim who is all over it, and also a guy with a beard (sorry can't remember his name). They both make the dining experience super fun. And haven't had to wait too long for food. The vibe is laid back and love the nostalgia.

another great night at Toby's. Deedee was cooking - that's always great, and Art had our drinks ready before we even ordered them. Better than Cheers!

I love Toby's ! Everything is perfect! Love all the people, nostalgia, music .. oh yes !! The people! They just made my Mother's Birthday perfect ! Food , Fun and lots of love

Great food, nice people, really slow. The mussels were plump and tender. We were informed on ordering they weren't local tonight (alge problem). Good none the less. Fantastic garlic bread. The various fried fish and shellfish we tried were good, as were the fries. The fresh salmon was a generous serving. The steak dinner worked. Our only concern was taking 2.5 hours for 2 courses, mussels and entrees.

First time at this establishment. Low key, down to earth, locals' joint. It's a small place overlooking the waters. We got there just in time as the place filled up fairly quickly for lunch (and we were told it was a slow day). If you come in during their busy time, expect a long wait. It is, what it is. Quaint town with a few restaurant = captive audience. So many items I wanted to try! Decided on Seafood Combo - think fish & chips, but it's Clam Strips, Shrimp & Cod served with French fries & Cole Slaw, $25. Portion size was good. Overall, it was good, not oily. The cod was flavorful (usually fish & chips dish tend to be on the bland side, but this wasn't). My companion ordered the Crispy Halibut Burger - served with lettuce, tomato, pickles, grilled onions, mayonnaise & French Fries, $13. Similar to my cod, the halibut was nicely seasoned. It's breaded on the outside (the crispy part of the name). Portion size was good. Overall, delicious. I'd come back again and try the other dishes on the menu. Service was good. Staff were friendly. There were only 2 servers for the place and they were hustling!

After nearly three years of coming to the island and looking across Penn Cove, I finally found the time to visit Toby's Tavern. Hearing lots about the downtown area and Toby's, I walked in on a Thursday about noon and it was relatively quiet with some locals enjoy small talk and some food. I was treated at the for by the woman behind the bar, offering me to sit anywhere at the bar. Having a set, I ordered a local beer (San Juan Outer Island IPA) and was given a menu. From what I had heard their fish and chips were excellent and the bartender added the mussels were just as good. I decided on the fish and chips for lunch. The first question I was asked, "where are you from?" Guess I didn't look local enough. I explained my soon to be mother-in-law lived on the opposite side of the cove and I'd been visiting on a very regular basis. She showed me some video of orcas in the cove, as I waited for my food. The establishment was clean and unique to Penn Cove. Definitely see as a local hangout when work ends. Friendly people, as I said hello to a few others in the bar. The food arrived and the meal was tasty. Four large pieces of fish served on a bed of chips with coleslaw and sides of tartar and cocktail sauce. I didn't have long to sit and relax, but enjoyed the quick visit. With Pen Cove Brewing no longer open, I might favor Toby's on more of a regular basis, when I am looking for a cold refreshing beer and some good local food. Can't wait to return for another meal!

Okay, this place is cool.... I love these old saloon-type places, super rustic and lots of cool things just hanging on the walls and from the ceiling! Good menu with lots of choices and pretty reasonable prices. Great views out the windows and lots to look at inside! I got the sirloin steak and it was pretty tasty. It lacked a good sear on it, but otherwise tasted good. Garlic bread was excellent, with a nice sear! Fries were also good, tasted very potato-ey, in a very positive way. Maybe cook them just a bit longer tho, but that might just be my taste. Service was friendly and quick and would definitely come back for the ambience AND the food.

(I'm not sure why my photos won't post in order, but they are pretty self explanatory. ) Toby's is 21 and up, which is so great to have an establishment for adults only. There aren't many that are 21 and up. But let me say, if you can't get time away from your kiddos, pick up a takeout order!!! The food is so DELICIOUS!!!!! I had a bit of absolutely everything. I ordered the bacon cheeseburger because you can't go wrong with a classic when trying a new place out! The burger was cooked to perfection, and the fries were hot and fresh. The seafood combination plate though!!!! Those clam strips have me anticipating the next time I go back!!! So tender, and the flavoring of the breading was on point! I also grabbed a bag of locally sourced, fresh coffee beans on the way out. And the depth, and richness of the coffee is heavenly. Our server was kind enough to let us try a sample too. If you stop in make sure you grab a bag for your favorite coffee lover! The bar itself looks, and gives the feel of a ol' mom and pop place, it looks old and is covered in decor, and memorabilia. There is so much to look at inside, and then you have a gorgeous view of the water on a nice day! Everyone knows the best food comes establishments that look like this!